黑料吃瓜群网

Bullying doctors a threat to patient safety


Wednesday, 07 November, 2018

Bullying doctors a threat to patient safety

Low level unprofessionalism by medical practitioners is a risk to patient safety,聽according to the authors of a Perspective published by the .

鈥淗ealth professionals consistently recognise the link between unprofessional behaviour and threats to patient safety and wellbeing,鈥 wrote Professor Johanna Westbrook, from the and colleagues.

It is associated with poor staff psychological wellbeing, including stress, reduced teamwork and communication, and loss of concentration.聽Less well understood, they said, was emerging evidence that 鈥渆ven low level unprofessionalism is a significant risk to patient safety鈥.

Unprofessional behaviour in the medical profession may range incivility through to passive aggression, public criticism of colleagues, deprecating humour, through to bullying, discrimination and harassment.

The 2016 survey of the found that 25% of staff in health agencies experienced bullying, and in a 2014 survey of the , 40% of nurses reported bullying or harassment in the previous 12 months.

In 2015, the found that 49% of respondents had been subjected to discrimination, bullying, harassment or sexual harassment. The released in 2017 its survey results: 34% of respondents had experienced bullying, 21.7% discrimination, 16.1% harassment and 6.2% sexual harassment.

鈥淭his behaviour can negatively affect staff satisfaction and staff absenteeism and retention, leading to costly staff turnover, and is associated with patient dissatisfaction, increased medico-legal risk and significant financial costs,鈥 the authors wrote.

鈥淔or example, a 鈥 trial showed that neonatal intensive care unit teams subjected to rudeness during a simulated management of a deteriorating infant performed significantly worse than teams treated respectfully by their expert observer. Rudeness resulted in less information sharing between team members, which compromised diagnostic performance and reduced help-seeking behaviour, contributing to poorer procedural performance compared with teams treated with civility.

鈥淎 large, multisite study in the US showed that patients whose surgeons received a high number of unsolicited patient reports of negative behaviour 鈥 experienced a 13.9% higher surgical and medical complication rate compared with surgeons with few such reports.鈥

The 2016 Senate inquiry into the medical complaints process in Australia recommended that governments, hospitals, specialty colleges and universities commit to eliminating bullying and harassment but, according to Westbrook and colleagues, 鈥減rovided little direction as to how this should occur鈥.

The authors outlined programs such as the Civility, Respect and Engagement in the Workplace (CREW) approach, developed and implemented across the US Veterans Health Administration nearly 20 years ago, and professional accountability programs which allow anonymous, online reporting of bad behaviour, with trained peer messengers conveying complaints to the subject of the report.

鈥淪uch programs signal an organisation鈥檚 desire to act and switch the focus of improving organisational culture to 鈥榚verybody鈥檚 business鈥,鈥 Westbrook and colleagues wrote.

鈥淚nternational attention has recently been drawn to allegations of unprofessional behaviour in other industries, from directors and actors in Hollywood to members of the British Parliament. However, the stakes in health care are greater with patient care at risk 鈥 It is time for health care to lead the way by adopting and rigorously evaluating organisational change programs,鈥 they concluded.

Image credit: 漏stock.adobe.com/au/Cherries

Related News

Nominations open for 2025 National Palliative Care Awards

Palliative Care Australia has announced that nominations are now open for the 2025 National...

"Damning statistics" from almost 1500 WA junior doctors

The AMA (WA) 黑料吃瓜群网 Health Check 2025 surveyed almost 1500 junior doctors — 30% who...

AMA: "Extreme Ahpra power used too readily"

The Australian Medical Association has called for changes to the law governing Ahpra, which it...



Content from other channels on our network


  • All content Copyright 漏 2025 黑料吃瓜群网-Farrow Pty Ltd